Let’s compare the human eye and the camera. They share similarities in function and structure, yet they also exhibit differences that highlight the capabilities of each. Both systems are designed to capture light and convert it to images. How that gets done is unique to each.
In this article, we’ll take a detailed look at the human eye and the modern camera, how they process light, and how each has specialized roles in human vision and photography.
Contents
- How are the Human Eye and the Camera Similar?
- Technological and Biological Differences in the Eye and the Camera
- What Form of Light can the Human Eye Detect?
- The Angle of View of the Human Eye and Camera Lenses
- Comparing Aperture with Iris
- Resolution and Detail in the Eye and Camera
- Sensitivity and Dynamic Range
- Fast Moving Objects
- 3D vs 2D
- Conclusion
- Take Away
How are the Human Eye and the Camera Similar?
The human eye and the modern digital camera serve similar functions in capturing images. The eye utilizes a complex biological structure. In contrast, digital cameras and even most compact cameras employ a sophisticated mechanical system.
Before we go further, let’s define some terms.
The Anatomy of the Eye
Cornea: the outermost, clear layer of the eye. A protective shield, the cornea filters some of the sun’s ultraviolet light.
Lens: the clear, curved structure at the front of the eye. It focuses light rays that enter the eye.
Iris: the tissue at the front of the eye. The iris controls the size of the pupil. Also, the pigmentation of this tissue gives the eye its color.
Pupil: the opening in the center of the iris. It lets light into the eye. It gets smaller in bright light and larger in dim light.
Retina: the light-sensitive tissue covering the back of the eyeball. Images passing through the eye’s lens are focused on the retina.
Optic Nerve: located at the back of each eye, this bundle of nerve fibers carries visual messages to the brain.
The Components of a Camera
Lens: an optical device with precision glass elements arranged to focus an image.
Aperture: the opening in a camera lens that controls how much light enters the camera. Similar to the iris and pupil in the eye.
Shutter: a mechanical device that controls the amount of time that light passes through a camera to expose the image. Some newer models transitioned this function from mechanical to electronic.
Sensor: an electronic device that absorbs light and converts it into electrical signals. These signals are then interpreted by a computer chip to produce a digital image.
Both the eye and the camera have a lens to focus an image, a method of adapting to the amount of light, and a light sensitive surface. And while one is a biological organ and the other an electromechanical device, they seem surprisingly similar in how they process images.
How do the Eye and the Camera Process Images?
The eye’s iris controls the amount of light entering the eye while the lens focuses the light. A light-sensitive surface at the rear of the eye, the retina, registers the subject. Then, the optic nerve transmits impulses from the retina to the brain, which interprets the image that you see.
A camera functions in much the same way. When light hits the camera’s lens, it is focused by adjusting the lens elements. The aperture controls the amount of light that passes into the camera. Then the light arrives at a light sensitive surface. In an earlier age of photography, that surface was film. But today, it is the image sensor, which sends electric signals to be processed by the camera’s circuitry.
Whether it be the eye or a camera, the received image is inverted. That is, it arrives upside-down because the lens in both the eye and the camera is convex or curved outward. When light enters a convex piece of glass or the lens of the human eye, it refracts, giving us an inverted image.
We don’t see the image upside-down because the human brain understands how the subject is supposed to appear and flips it right-side up. Digital cameras employ circuitry to make that correction.
Technological and Biological Differences in the Eye and the Camera
The human eye and the camera differ in significant ways.
- How the image is focused
- How they process color.
- The eye has a blind spot.
- The eye perceives an image while the camera captures an image.
Focusing the Image
The eye’s lens changes shape to maintain focus on an object. The thickness of the lens expands or contracts and tiny muscles attached to the lens accomplish this.
Camera lenses acquire focus by changing the position of glass elements. The photographer turns the focus ring, which changes the lens elements’ relationship to each other. Alternatively, the camera’s autofocus system accomplishes this when the photographer presses the shutter button halfway to acquire focus.
Processing Color
The retina of the human eye contains rods and cones, two types of photoreceptors. The rod cells enable us to see in low-lighting conditions. Cones give us color vision. Three types of cones respond to varying wavelengths of light. Red cones detect the long wavelengths. Green cones are sensitive to medium wavelengths. And blue cones interpret the shorter wavelengths.
A digital camera contains only one type of photoreceptor, the sensor. However, an array of color filters – red, green, and blue – cover this device. When light hits it, each pixel of this imaging sensor records the intensity of light that passes through its respective filter. Then, the camera’s processor collates these signals to construct a full-color image.
The Eye’s Blind Spot
Since a camera’s sensor contains photoreceptors evenly distributed over its entire surface, it sees the full picture. However, the human eye has a blind spot. The area of the retina where the optic nerve connects contains no photoreceptors.
However, we don’t notice the blind spot. That’s because when light hits that area of one eye, the other eye fills in the gaps and the brain processes the information to give us the full picture.
Image Perception or Image Capture
The human eye functions as a complex biological organ, allowing us to perceive the world in real-time. In contrast, a digital camera operates as an electromechanical device for image capture and recording. While the eye provides immediate and continuous visual feedback, the digital camera preserves moments for future viewing. In this sense, the human eye is similar to the video camera.
What Form of Light can the Human Eye Detect?
Human eyes see visible light, which sounds obvious. However, visible light is a small segment of the electromagnetic spectrum. This range encompasses wavelengths from approximately 400 to 700 nanometers. We humans perceive colors from violet to red. Green light is most visible to humans. However, in dim light, yellow is most visible.
The relationship between eyesight and light
The human eye detects light through specialized cells, rods, and cones in the retina. These rod and cone cells convert light into electrical signals that the brain interprets.
Light is essential for the eyes to perceive the world, as it enables the retina to detect images. Variations in light intensity and quality can significantly affect visual clarity and color perception, highlighting the intricate connection between light and the ability to see.
The Angle of View of the Human Eye and Camera Lenses
One aspect that differentiates human vision from the capabilities of camera lenses is the field of view (FOV). The human field of view is 120-200 degrees, which includes the dual-eye overlap region and peripheral vision. That’s an angle of view that compares to an ultra-wide angle lens. However, much of that is peripheral vision. Therefore, the central angle of view for human vision is more like 40-60 degrees. And that is comparable to a 43-50mm lens on a full-frame camera.
In contrast, camera lenses have a precisely defined field of view, which is determined by their focal length. A 50mm lens typically offers a FOV of around 48 degrees, while a wide-angle lens expands the field of view to 180 degrees or more. Meanwhile, a telephoto lens of 600mm narrows the field of view to 3.4 degrees.
The Eye Perceives While the Camera Captures
In addition, the eye’s ability to quickly shift focus and adjust to varying light conditions enables a dynamic and immersive experience of the environment. The curved back of the eye, the retina, captures a rich array of colors and details, providing a continuous stream of visual information. Then, the brain processes that information in real-time, creating a seamless perception of the world.
Unlike the human eye, a camera requires adjustments to settings such as aperture and shutter speed to capture images effectively. Additionally, cameras record static images or sequences of images. As such, they lack the fluidity and depth of perception that human vision provides and virtually no periphery of the visual field.
The One Lens That is Equivalent to the Human Eye
We measure the focal length of a lens from optical center of the lens to the sensor. The human eye has a focal length between 17-24mm. That’s a wide-angle field of view that compares to a fisheye lens. Discounting peripheral vision, the center of the human field of view is comparable to a full-frame camera lens of 43-50mm.
We consider the 50mm normal focal length the lens that most closely resembles the perspective of the human eye. Again, that’s on a full-frame camera. This focal length provides a natural field of view, allowing photographers to create images that reflect how we perceive the world around us.
Comparing Aperture with Iris
In photography, f-stop tells us how much light enters the lens and sets the exposure (along with shutter speed and ISO). The maximum f-stop is calculated as the ratio of the focal length of the lens and the diameter of the wide-open aperture. Therefore, a 200mm lens with a wide-open diameter of 100mm equals f/2.
The human eye, with the focal length previously referenced at 17-24mm, has a pupil diameter of 8mm at maximum. So, that equals an f-stop of f/2.1-f3.8. This compares favorably to high-quality lenses available today.
Resolution and Detail in the Eye and Camera
Resolution capabilities of the human eye and cameras reveal significant differences. The human eye detects a wide range of colors and variations in light. It has a visual ability to perceive fine details in texture and subtle gradations of color. Scientists estimate that the eye can resolve about 576 megapixels of visual data. That figure is part of theory, as the brain processes visual information in a way that is difficult to quantify.
In contrast, digital cameras capture image files with precise pixel counts. High-end cameras and the best cell phone cameras exceed 100 megapixels. Highly specialized cameras, such as those operated by NASA or the Vera Rubin Observatory in Chile, have very high resolution.
Cameras produce highly detailed pictures with excellent contrast and texture. And modern cameras yield files that are capable of rendering realistic looking prints. Photographers use composition methods such as central vision and symmetry to draw the viewers attention to the main subject.
Most cameras fail to replicate the detail, dynamic range, and adaptability of the human eye. That’s because the eye can adjust to varying light conditions and focus on different depths simultaneously. On the other hand, cameras fitted with specialized lenses look deep into space or examine the microscopic cells of the human body.
Sensitivity and Dynamic Range
Human eyes and digital cameras exhibit remarkable sensitivity and high dynamic range, each with unique capabilities to adapt to varying light conditions. The human eye detects a range of light intensities, a dynamic range of 10–14 f-stops, which is similar to digital SLR cameras.
The sensitivity of the eye varies depending on the lighting conditions. In bright light, it’s estimated to have equivalent ISO speeds of one to 1,000, about 16,000 in low light, and 800,000 at night. The eye functions effectively in both bright sunlight and low-light conditions. This adaptability is due to the presence of rod and cone cells in the retina, which enable the eye to adjust to changes in brightness and darkness almost instantaneously.
Digital SLR cameras are designed to operate across a wide range of light intensities. However, the sensitivity is limited compared to that of the human eye. While modern photography achieves impressive results through advanced imaging technology and processing algorithms, the medium struggles with extreme contrasts. That is, a combination of the bright light of midday and the dim light of shadows leads to a loss of detail in one or both of these areas.
This can be mitigated with high dynamic range (HDR) photography using multiple exposures. In addition, cameras can approach the night-time performance of human eyes with longer exposures.
Fast Moving Objects
The human eye and the digital camera both employ methods to detect objects moving at high speed. The eye utilizes a complex system of photoreceptors. And when an object moves quickly, the eye’s ability to track it relies on the brain’s processing speed and the eye’s muscle coordination. Thus, the eye allows for smooth tracking and perception of motion.
In contrast, digital cameras capture photos of fast-moving subjects with shutters capable of 1/4,000 sec and faster. Even compact cameras can capture rapid movement. Both the eye and the camera are adept at perceiving and capturing motion. But they do so through different physiological and technological processes.
3D vs 2D
The human eye perceives three-dimensional subjects. This results from the brain’s ability to process information from two slightly different perspectives: the right eye and the left eye. This binocular vision allows for depth perception. Therefore, humans judge distances and spatial relationships effectively.
In contrast, cameras capture photos in two dimensions, recording light on a flat camera sensor surface without the depth cues that the human brain interprets. As a result, while the eye can create a sense of volume and space, a camera’s image appears flat, lacking the dimensionality that the human visual system naturally provides.
Conclusion
The human eye possesses a remarkable ability to detect a wide dynamic range of light, focus quickly, and perceive depth and motion with precision. A camera has the unique ability to capture and preserve images, store vast amounts of data, and utilize a wide variety of lenses taking us into new frontiers.
Together, with all their differences and similarities, they enhance our visual experiences, understanding of the world and beyond, and the art of photography.
If you have any questions or comments, please submit them in the space below.
Take Away
The human eye and the digital camera excel at their functions. The eye is a complex biological organ that adjusts to changes in light and motion without thinking and perceives the world in real time. The camera, with its advanced system of optics and electronics, allows photographers to capture a moment or reveal something about a person’s character or personality that goes unnoticed by the eye.
